"MyBestDatingSites" is an independent & fully unbiased initiative. You can help keep this peer-based project alive & free by donating. Your support is much appreciated!

Plenty Of Fish vs Tinder - Quick Overview

By conducting side by side Plenty Of Fish vs Tinder online dating site comparison, we have divided this in-depth comparison report into 8 different groups of features to achieve deeper and more technical result analysis. Looking at the overall score, it’s clear that Plenty Of Fish is leading with a score of 9.6, whereas Tinder has earned a score of 8.1.

Looking at the value for money - a feature that represents - it’s obvious that Plenty Of Fish takes the lead with a score of 4.8 stars (out of 5), while Tinder was evaluated with 4.1 stars.

These two brands were also compared with the best-rated leading dating site - Elite Singles. According to thorough research, Elite Singles has gathered an overall score of 9.8, while its value for money reached 4.9 stars. This report of the most important dating sites’ features reveal that Elite Singles is the leader. You can check the more detailed, in-depth comparison results below.

Compare Other Dating Sites

Swipe right to compare

Horizontal scroll hint
Elite Singles
ELITE SINGLES
Plenty Of Fish
PLENTY OF FISH
Tinder
TINDER

Overall Score

9.8
9.6
8.1

Best For

Best for Well-educated & Succesfull People Best for Serious Relationship Best for Hookups

Dominating Gender

Female Male Female/Male

Verdict

A great dating site for well-educated people in their thirties who want aren't afraid to spend a bit of money. One of the oldest and most popular dating sites for people in their lates 20s and early 30s. App that allows you to make connections easily by swiping right.
Visit site
Read review
Visit site
Read review
Visit site
Read review

Plenty Of Fish vs Tinder Detailed Comparison

Take a look at the most comprehensive Plenty Of Fish vs Tinder dating site comparison below. Here, you’ll be able to quickly compare every feature of the dating sites, eliminating uncertainty and guessing. Browse this fact-based research wiki and choose the winner!

Compare Other Dating Sites

Swipe right to compare

Horizontal scroll hint
Elite Singles
ELITE SINGLES
Plenty Of Fish
PLENTY OF FISH
Tinder
TINDER

Pros

  • Educated individuals
  • More than 400,000 users per month
  • Female-dominated
  • LGBT-friendly
  • Huge user base
  • Mobile app
  • Very simple to use
  • Personality-test based
  • Automatic and manual matchmaking
  • Make connections easily
  • Amazing features
  • Members of LGBTQ+ are free to join

Cons

  • Very pricey
  • Very poor mobile app design
  • Lacks freedom of choice for the user
  • Dated site design
  • Not LGBT-friendly
  • Messaging is completely free
  • Lacks profile customization
  • Matches based on looks

Ease of Use

Customer Support

Latest Coupons

All Elite Singles Coupons All Plenty Of Fish Coupons See All Coupons of Best Dating Sites
Audience Info

Registered User Count

400K 90M 57M

Fake User Count

|
|
|
|
|
Very Low
Average
Very High
|
|
|
|
|
Very Low
Average
Very High
|
|
|
|
|
Very Low
Average
Very High

Dominating Age Group

Over 30 20-30 18-24

LGBT-Friendly

International

Features

Personality Test

Matching System Quality

|
|
|
|
|
Very Poor
Average
Excellent
|
|
|
|
|
Very Poor
Average
Excellent
|
|
|
|
|
Very Poor
Average
Excellent

Value For Money

Desktop App

|
|
|
|
|
Very Poor
Average
Excellent
|
|
|
|
|
Very Poor
Average
Excellent
|
|
|
|
|
Very Poor
Average
Excellent

Mobile App

|
|
|
|
|
Very Poor
Average
Excellent
|
|
|
|
|
Very Poor
Average
Excellent
|
|
|
|
|
Very Poor
Average
Excellent

Manual/Automatic matching

Automatic Manual Manual

Safety

|
|
|
|
|
Very Poor
Average
Excellent
|
|
|
|
|
Very Poor
Average
Excellent
|
|
|
|
|
Very Poor
Average
Excellent
Free/Paid features

Message Other Users

Paid Free Free

Send Custom Messages

Paid Free Free

See who read your message

Paid Free Free

Who's Cheking Profile

Paid Paid Paid

Customize profile

Paid Paid Free

View Other Profiles

Free Free Free

Receive Partners Suggest

Free Paid Paid
Pricing

Monthly payment

$22.95 $12.90 $4.15

Free Version

Number Of Plans

3 3 6

Money Back Guarantee

1 1 1
Company’s info

Full Company Name

Elite Singles Plenty Of Fish Tinder

Headquarters

Dover, Delaware Vancouver, Canada Hollywood, CA

Year of Origin

2008 2003 2012
Quotes about the dating site

Most Positive Comment

-The amount of users is less significant than in other popular dating websites +Significantly less fake accounts than in other popular dating websites Not Allen

the app seems a bit lagging but the desktop version works great! Plenty of beautiful fish indeed, if you want casual dates or serious, this is your game! Cody Hussain

I don't have many matches. People decide only by looks. Tylor Mclellan

Expert Comment

Expert comment

Elite Singles is a dating platform aimed at well-educated, successful people. The majority of the site’s users are over 30, have successful careers and are looking... read more Aaron S. - Expert Reviewer

Expert comment

Plenty of Fish is a veteran online dating site that offers users a lot of different features. It has a huge number of users, good security systems, and also provides some... read more Aaron S. - Expert Reviewer

Expert comment

Tinder accepts members of LGBTQ+. What is more, it’s... read more Laura M. - Chief Editor

Check Official Website

Compare Other Dating Sites

Which is better - Plenty Of Fish vs Tinder? Let’s find out with this thorough analysis.

This in-depth Plenty Of Fish vs Tinder online dating site comparison reveals that Plenty Of Fish is ahead while evaluating value for money. It seems like Plenty Of Fish has price VS quality ratio figured out quite fairly. Talking about the user base of these two brands, it’s clear that Plenty Of Fish has the bigger user base with 90M users, whereas Tinder takes the second place.

In this Plenty Of Fish vs Tinder comparison, lower fake user count can be seen in Plenty Of Fish. The better matching system quality is offered by Tinder. Talking about the quality and usability of the mobile app, Plenty Of Fish takes the cake in this category with an overall excellent mobile app using experience. After evaluating another highly important online dating site feature - safety - it’s clear that Tinder is more secure and trustworthy among the two brands.

Now let’s look at the pricing, which is a significant factor to consider before choosing an online dating site. The cheaper price for a month is offered by Tinder with a price tag of $4.15. The second according to the pricing is Plenty Of Fish with a payment of $12.90 per month. It's evident that the longer money back guarantee is offered by Plenty Of Fish. Finally, after evaluating all these important factors, the better-rated brand in this Plenty Of Fish vs Tinder online dating site comparison is Plenty Of Fish!

If comparing only Plenty Of Fish vs Tinder brands, Plenty Of Fish may seem like a winner, but not when this brand is put against other best-rated online dating sites in the market. According to our fact-based analysis & comparing with the brands that you chose, Elite Singles is by far a better choice and is rated as the most recommended dating site out there.

Summary

The Plenty Of Fish vs Tinder online dating site comparison tool revealed that Plenty Of Fish has better features & higher in-depth evaluation scores than Tinder.

But when comparing these brands to the whole dating site market, Elite Singles takes the lead as the best-rated online dating site among its competitors and is a more suited choice for you.

Read Full Elite Singles Review

Best User Reviews of Compared Dating Sites

5.0/5.0 - Elite Singles User
2020-10-04

At first, I was quite scared because of all the negative feedback about dating websites in general. But I feel very lucky I come across Elite Singles. Even though I' a newbie in the dating world I feel like this is the most welcoming and interesting community out there.

4.8/5.0 - Elite Singles User
2020-10-13

The website and the app feels a little outdated. However I m pretty much positive about other aspects

4.8/5.0 - Plenty of Fish User
2020-10-05

Yes, it is free and super easy to use but because of its huge user base, there is a lot of trolling and "not for the dating" people.

Read All Elite Singles User Reviews

VS
Elite Singles
ELITE SINGLES
Plenty Of Fish
PLENTY OF FISH
9.8
9.6
VS
Elite Singles
ELITE SINGLES
OkCupid
OKCUPID
9.8
9.4
VS
Elite Singles
ELITE SINGLES
Christian Mingle
CHRISTIAN MINGLE
9.8
9.1


How Is the Plenty Of Fish vs Tinder Comparison Created?

We scan Plenty Of Fish vs Tinder

1. We scan

To make this Plenty Of Fish vs Tinder comparison as accurate as possible, we search for fact-based, honest information about each brand. All the most important online dating sites’ features are gathered from multiple reliable sources.

We investigate Plenty Of Fish vs Tinder

2. We investigate

The gathered information is then aggregated & analyzed by expert researchers. In this way, the final evaluations of each feature in this Plenty Of Fish vs Tinder online dating site comparison are presented with accuracy & trustworthiness.

We compare Plenty Of Fish vs Tinder

3. We compare

All the most important features of online dating sites are disclosed & put head-to-head in the comprehensive Plenty Of Fish vs Tinder comparison chart. In this way, it’s easy to measure different brands against each other with just a short glance.

You pick Plenty Of Fish vs Tinder

4. You pick

Once you have all the most important online dating site features evaluated & presented to you side by side for this Plenty Of Fish vs Tinder comparison, it’s super easy to just pick out your favourite brand & reach your online dating goals in no time!

FAQ

What are the most important features in this Plenty Of Fish vs Tinder online dating site comparison?

In this Plenty Of Fish vs Tinder or any other online dating site brand comparison, the most important features to take into account are user demographics, purpose of the site, safety features, pricing, functionality & ease of use. All these features and more are always evaluated & presented in our in-depth dating site comparison research wiki.

How do you make sure that the information presented in this Plenty Of Fish vs Tinder online dating site comparison is reliable & fact-based?

We have a clear, strict process for collecting only honest, factual data. For that, we use only trustworthy & reliable sources, whether it’s real user feedback or statistical information. Any kind of false marketing claims or unbacked opinions are filtered out of the evaluation process. In this way you can be sure that the measurements presented in our comparison wiki are truthful & accurate.

How should I choose the most suitable dating site for me?

Choosing the right online dating site is a big step towards reaching your dating achievements. Since there are a lot of different online dating site options, it may seem overwhelming and time consuming to scan through all of them. No worries - we have done all the research for you. Just use this ultimate online dating site comparison tool - pick the brands you want to compare & view all the most important aspects measured against each other for each brand. You will instantly see which online dating site is perfect for you!

How is the Online Dating Site Comparison Tool used?

Firstly, you have to choose the online dating brands you want to compare in the input fields above. Click “Compare Now” & you will get two charts. One with generalized main information & the other with more detailed various feature comparison. Simply browse the dating site comparison charts & compare your chosen online dating sites side by side for each feature. You should be able to make your pick easily!

Which features matter the most while doing dating site comparison?

The most important features to take into account while you compare dating sites are the purpose of the online dating site, demographics, pricing, user base, ease of use & safety measures. Without comparing these factors, choosing the best site can be tricky. Luckily, we have all of that covered in our dating site comparison wiki. All of the most important features and more are measured head to head for each online dating brand.

How can I choose the best online dating site?

First of all, you need to clarify your primary intention, whether it’s finding a long-term partner or just a hookup. This step is essential because there are many different online dating sites, and if you choose wrong, you’ll be wasting your time in the wrong area. It’s also vital to find out the general user audience of each dating site you’re researching, as well as the safety and anti-scam policies. It’s also crucial that the site is really trustworthy. It might seem like a struggle to figure this all out, but we’ve done all the research for you. Take a look at the best online dating sites list.